No Real Roots Issue

No Real Roots Issue - 消息

#1 已发布: 2020/7/3 09:57:17
ianlh

ianlh

0个赞,共38个帖子。

组: User

Hi,

I am a bit stumped with a what is probably a simple problem. I have a root solve in Mathcad that I just cant get to work in Smath, I have tried what I think is correct ways, but still not working, see below for example:
Mcad1.JPG
Smath1.JPG

I have also tried stripping out the units, but still no luck
Hoping someone has the simple solution.
Ian
#2 已发布: 2020/7/3 13:05:46
Jean Giraud

Jean Giraud

983个赞,共6,866个帖子。

组: User

Always plot before solving !

Solve UNK.sm (212.45 KiB)已下载 1156 次。
#3 已发布: 2020/7/3 19:03:05
overlord

overlord

600个赞,共1,381个帖子。

组: Moderator

Wrote

Hi,

I am a bit stumped with a what is probably a simple problem. I have a root solve in Mathcad that I just cant get to work in Smath, I have tried what I think is correct ways, but still not working, see below for example:
Mcad1.JPG
Smath1.JPG

I have also tried stripping out the units, but still no luck
Hoping someone has the simple solution.
Ian


I have tried on Mathcad and it didn't work either.
Obviously there is a mistake with the formula.
You can't add kg*N/s^2 with kg/s^2. Units mismatch.
But if you divide the givens you can get the correct answer.
If this approach is true of course since we don't have more information.

Regards.

correct.png
#4 已发布: 2020/7/3 21:37:54
overlord

overlord

600个赞,共1,381个帖子。

组: Moderator

Jean, direct question;
Are you being sarcastic about my comment?
#5 已发布: 2020/7/4 09:14:08
Jean Giraud

Jean Giraud

983个赞,共6,866个帖子。

组: User

Wrote

Jean, direct question;
Are you being sarcastic about my comment?


I have removed my comment.
In my times, maths were unitless working well.
Now, put units in maths ... red results.
#6 已发布: 2020/7/4 15:00:31
Alvaro

Alvaro

1,139个赞,共1,805个帖子。

组: User

Wrote

Hi,

I am a bit stumped with a what is probably a simple problem. I have a root solve in Mathcad that I just cant get to work in Smath, I have tried what I think is correct ways, but still not working, see below for example:

I have also tried stripping out the units, but still no luck
Hoping someone has the simple solution.
Ian



Hi. Your setup is correct for Mathcad, but unfortunately SMath's solvers do not works like in Mathcad, and needs some help for use units.

SolveWithUnits.sm (16.17 KiB)已下载 1153 次。

Clipboard02.gif

Best regards.
Alvaro
3位用户喜欢此帖子
Вячеслав Мезенцев 2020/7/4 15:43:00, frapuano 2020/7/5 03:18:00, sergio 2020/7/5 12:07:00
#7 已发布: 2020/7/4 16:16:18
overlord

overlord

600个赞,共1,381个帖子。

组: Moderator

I have checked with changing all inputs;
somehow the two formula give same calculation every time.

Regards

correct2.png
#8 已发布: 2020/7/5 07:29:58
ianlh

ianlh

0个赞,共38个帖子。

组: User

Hi All,

Thanks for the help with this, I like the solution by Alvaro, seems the most elegant.
#9 已发布: 2020/7/5 10:14:25
Jean Giraud

Jean Giraud

983个赞,共6,866个帖子。

组: User

Unless you don't agree with yourself, solving SQRT implies the two solutions.
Presumably delimiting the range of the solvable project.

SQRTsolve.PNG
#10 已发布: 2020/7/5 14:30:31
Alvaro

Alvaro

1,139个赞,共1,805个帖子。

组: User

Wrote

I have checked with changing all inputs;
somehow the two formula give same calculation every time.

Regards



Hi Overlord. You found an amazing symbolic solution for the original problem. I can't explain why, but my guess is that f1, f2 and f3 must to be related with the directors cosines or something like that.

Maple shows that your solution and the symbolic solution are the same, but must to force some "not-always-true" reductions in maple, with the command "maple(simplify(expression,symbolic))"

SolveWithUnits overlord.sm (35.13 KiB)已下载 1181 次。
SolveWithUnits overlord.pdf (97.32 KiB)已下载 818 次。

Best regards.
Alvaro.

1位用户喜欢此帖子
overlord 2020/7/15 17:54:00
#11 已发布: 2020/7/6 04:43:09
Martin Kraska

Martin Kraska

1,362个赞,共2,276个帖子。

组: Moderator

Once Maxima and the Maxima plugin are installed, you have a symbolic solver without unit issues.

solve.png
solve.sm (9.99 KiB)已下载 1147 次。
Technische Mechanik mit SMath Studio: https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-658-50592-9
1位用户喜欢此帖子
Alvaro 2020/7/6 12:50:00
  • 有新帖
  • 无新帖