1页(5条)
Replicating MathCAD given and find function to solve Castigliano curved beam deflection - Replicating MathCAD given and find function to solve Castigliano curved beam deflection - 消息
I used the old MathCAD before MathCAD prime to solve Castigliano theorem with the Given and Find function;

I found a MathCAD Toolbox plugin within SMath Solver to use the solve block function that I hoped would be able to replicate this functionality however I cannot get this solver to find a solution!

I attach the worksheet from SMath Solver.
Castigliano5.sm (15.06 KiB)已下载 677 次。
The first derivatives 3 parts solve similar to MathCAD however even plugging in values for the variables I cannot get the solve block to replicate what could be achieved with MathCAD in terms of given and find!
Can anyone please advise on how to replicate this functionality within SMath Solver to mimic old MathCAD as I am a newbie while using SMath Solver and hope to replace MathCAD with SMath Solver?

I found a MathCAD Toolbox plugin within SMath Solver to use the solve block function that I hoped would be able to replicate this functionality however I cannot get this solver to find a solution!

I attach the worksheet from SMath Solver.
Castigliano5.sm (15.06 KiB)已下载 677 次。
The first derivatives 3 parts solve similar to MathCAD however even plugging in values for the variables I cannot get the solve block to replicate what could be achieved with MathCAD in terms of given and find!
Can anyone please advise on how to replicate this functionality within SMath Solver to mimic old MathCAD as I am a newbie while using SMath Solver and hope to replace MathCAD with SMath Solver?
This is roughly how it is done in Mathcad, but getting the same result is not so easy.


Castigliano5.sm (9.72 KiB)已下载 625 次。


Castigliano5.sm (9.72 KiB)已下载 625 次。
已编辑 2026/6/29 14:50:15
Russia ☭ forever, Viacheslav N. Mezentsev
3位用户喜欢此帖子
Thanks sir I am impressed you could quickly roughly get a solve! I wanted to check with you that the .1888056555e is the mathematical constant e (euler's number)? The expression matches with the 3*R^3*F/El almost just the constant is a little different!
No, it's an exponential representation of a number.
Russia ☭ forever, Viacheslav N. Mezentsev
Hi. Numeric solution.

Castigliano5 al_nleqsolve.sm (10.48 KiB)已下载 619 次。
Or

Castigliano5 NR.sm (13.66 KiB)已下载 619 次。
Best regards.
Alvaro.

Castigliano5 al_nleqsolve.sm (10.48 KiB)已下载 619 次。
Or

Castigliano5 NR.sm (13.66 KiB)已下载 619 次。
Best regards.
Alvaro.
已编辑 2026/7/1 06:08:22
4位用户喜欢此帖子
sergio 2026/7/1 07:55:46, Вячеслав Мезенцев 2026/7/1 08:40:49, NDTM Amarasekera 2026/7/1 14:47:59, ioan92 2026/7/3 08:39:07
1页(5条)
- 有新帖
- 无新帖